by Chiba City Blues » April 22nd, 2012, 8:57 pm
Is Phantasie worth checking out? To be quiet honest, they were great games for their time, but, having retried the games in emulation in the 2000s, only Phantasie 3 is still worth playing. The interface in the first two games is so archaic that they're almost a chore to play.
To be fair, by the time I tried Phantasie 2 on my C64, I had (in addition to playing its sequel) already played Wasteland, Bard's Tale 3, and Final Fantasy 4, all of which have vastly superior interfaces.
This isn't a knock against old games in general (Hell, I'm replaying Wasteland right now), as I had a few grating issues with Super Paper Mario, mainly dealing with the fact that the game came out in 2007, and yet I played games from the 1980s with less grating inventory management systems. JRPGs generally had crap inventory management systems until close to the mid-1990s (try playing an early Dragon Warrior or Final Fantasy game, and then play an Interplay RPG from the same era to see what I mean), but some of them got very good at it afterwards, particularly Square games, which is somewhat ironic given as how the first Final Fantasy was among the worst offenders when it came to interface design.